Playing Defense in Optical Sales
Optical sales account for 60% or more of revenue in many private practices. Traditionally, we’ve focused on KPIs like capture rate, staff bonuses on upgrades, and maximizing insurance reimbursements. The higher the capture rate, the higher the compensation for optical staff. The logic has been simple: the higher the capture rate, the stronger the practice.
But here’s the problem: the strategies haven’t changed. We continue to hear the same tactics—discounting, price-matching, negotiating with labs, or private labeling. Meanwhile, the landscape has shifted. Online retailers have sold tens of millions of pairs of glasses so far and will continue to grow. Managed care increasingly directs patients to optical chains, and online retailers like Zenni sell glasses for $15—an impossible price point to compete with. Even corporate opticals are struggling to keep pace with the online market.
The future of optometry lies in expanding scope of practice, leveraging AI for administrative tasks, and moving beyond reliance on optical sales alone.
So, what happens when all the traditional “offense” strategies fail? After exhausting every effort to capture the sale, it’s time to think differently: play defense. Just as in sports, defense can win championships—why not use the same approach to strengthen our profession long-term?
Here’s how I play defense when patients are determined to buy glasses online—something many of them have done for years without issue:
- Contact Lenses for New Wearers – Introduce them as affordable, practical alternatives: (Ortho K, daily lenses, extended wear contact lens.
- Refractive Surgery – If the patient is a candidate, recommend LASIK as a glasses-free option.
- Cataract Surgery with Premium IOLs – For appropriate patients, discuss lens implants that reduce or eliminate the need for glasses.
- Presbyopia Drops (e.g.,Vizz) – Offer cutting-edge solutions for patients who want freedom from reading glasses.
Playing defense isn’t about giving up on optical—it’s about protecting the value of our profession. Stop fueling online retailers. Too many ODs avoid this approach out of fear it will hurt their dispensary if they fit cl or rx a presbyopia drop. But when a patient is already set on purchasing elsewhere, refusing to play defense only fuels online retailers and undermines the role of optometry. By expanding the conversation and offering alternatives, we provide real value, build trust, and protect our profession in the long run but not supporting our competitors.
